Dasani vs Aquafina vs smartwater: what's in them

Dasani, Aquafina and smartwater are all purified waters: treated, often from a city water supply, until almost nothing is left in them. What sets them apart is what goes back in. Aquafina adds nothing. Dasani adds a little magnesium, potassium and salt, and smartwater adds the most, mainly calcium chloride.

MeasureDasaniAquafinasmartwater
Total dissolved solids mg/L30lab test, 2017NDbrand report, 2025209lab test, 2017
pH 6.1lab test, 20175.6lab test, 20176.3lab test, 2017
Calcium mg/L<0.2lab test, 2017<0.2lab test, 201764.1lab test, 2017
Magnesium mg/L2.9lab test, 2017<0.1lab test, 20174.6lab test, 2017
Sodium mg/L3.8lab test, 20170.3lab test, 2017<0.1lab test, 2017
Potassium mg/L2.9lab test, 2017<0.1lab test, 20174.4lab test, 2017
Bicarbonate mg/L10lab test, 20175lab test, 201722lab test, 2017
Sulfate mg/L11lab test, 20170–0.49brand report, 2025<2lab test, 2017
Chloride mg/L4.1lab test, 20170–0.65brand report, 2025125lab test, 2017
Fluoride mg/L0.07dataset, 2005NDbrand report, 2025–
Total hardness mg/L as CaCO₃12calculated0–1calculated179calculated
Alkalinity mg/L as CaCO₃8calculated4calculated18calculated
For coffee SCA standardOutsideOutsideOutside
For espresso machinesVery softVery softScale or corrosion risk
Hardness class USGSSoftSoftHard

Dasani and smartwater are Coca-Cola brands that publish only pass-or-fail reports. Their values come from a 2017 lab test of one bottle each, and from label values recorded around 2020. Aquafina's come from its 2025 report and the same 2017 lab tests.

Aquafina: as close to pure water as it gets

Aquafina's own 2025 report found no measurable dissolved solids. In the 2017 lab test it had under 0.2 mg/L of calcium and 0.3 mg/L of sodium. With nothing to buffer it, its pH reads slightly acidic (5.6), as purified water often does once it takes up carbon dioxide from the air.

Dasani: a pinch of minerals for taste

Dasani's label lists magnesium sulfate, potassium chloride and salt. In the lab test they came to 2.9 mg/L of magnesium, 2.9 mg/L of potassium and 3.8 mg/L of sodium, about 30 mg/L of dissolved solids in all. That's still very soft water.

smartwater: more minerals than you'd expect

smartwater is distilled, then calcium chloride, magnesium chloride and potassium bicarbonate are added. The lab test found 64.1 mg/L of calcium, 125 mg/L of chloride and 209 mg/L of dissolved solids, which is more than many spring waters. All that calcium makes it hard water, about 179 mg/L as calcium carbonate.

Which one to choose

  • For the purest water: Aquafina. Store-brand purified waters bottled by Niagara, such as Kirkland Signature, are much the same.
  • For a few minerals added back: Dasani.
  • For coffee: smartwater has the calcium the SCA's standard asks for (calcium hardness about 160 mg/L) but almost no alkalinity (18 mg/L, against 40–70), so coffee brewed with it can taste sour. Aquafina and Dasani have too few minerals to brew well.
  • For espresso machines: makers such as Breville say not to use distilled, reverse-osmosis or demineralized water, which rules out Aquafina and Dasani. smartwater's chloride is far above the 30 mg/L makers allow. See water for a Breville.