How we rate bottled water

Every number on this site comes from a published source, and every rating applies a published standard. This page explains both.

Where the numbers come from

For each mineral of each water we use the best source that reports it, in this order:

  1. The brand's own water quality report, newest first. Most large US brands publish one each year, often because California requires it.
  2. The brand's website, where a product page lists minerals.
  3. An archived copy of one of the brand's older reports, such as a copy kept by the Internet Archive or posted by another site.
  4. An independent lab test or a study. The lab tests are of single bottles bought in 2017 and 2018, tested by NSF Erdmann Analytics in Germany for the owner of Aqua Carpatica, a competing brand, which published them. The study is Stoots et al. 2021, which recorded the mineral values printed on bottle labels around 2020.
  5. A dataset: the USDA's 2005 database of fluoride in beverages, for fluoride only.

So one water's page can mix sources, for example calcium from this year's report and bicarbonate from a lab test, and the page says which is which. Store brands such as Kirkland Signature and Great Value are bottled by companies like Niagara Bottling, so their values are the bottler's published averages for that type of water.

Units and conventions

Hardness and alkalinity

Where a source doesn't report them, we work them out from the minerals, in mg/L as calcium carbonate, and mark them as calculated:

The factors come from the atomic weights: calcium carbonate weighs 100.09 against calcium's 40.08 and magnesium's 24.31, and bicarbonate counts 50.04 per equivalent against its own 61.02.

Coffee

We compare each water with the Specialty Coffee Association's water specification in Standard 102-2024: calcium hardness 50–175 mg/L, alkalinity 40–70 mg/L and pH 6–8. A water inside all three "meets the SCA standard". If it's also inside the SCA's 2009 brewing targets (calcium hardness 50–85, pH 6.5–7.5, dissolved solids 75–250), we say so.

Few bottled waters meet the standard, so the coffee list ranks them by distance. For each measure outside its range we take the shortfall or excess as a share of the nearest limit (pH in pH units), add them up, and add 0.1 for each measure the sources don't report. Where a source gives a range, we average the scores of its two ends. The lowest score ranks first. Sparkling waters aren't ranked for coffee or espresso.

Espresso machines

We use the two full manufacturer specifications we could find, La Marzocco's and Lelit's, taking the stricter bound where both give one: total hardness 70–100 mg/L, alkalinity 40–75 mg/L, dissolved solids 90–150 mg/L, chloride under 30 mg/L, pH 6.5–8, and sulfate under 50 mg/L when listed. A water is "machine-friendly" inside all of them, "very soft" with dissolved solids under 90 or hardness under 70 (where makers' advice differs), and a "scale or corrosion risk" over any maximum.

Where pH, calcium, alkalinity and dissolved solids are all known, we also give the Langelier saturation index at 93 °C, the boiler temperature La Marzocco models. We calculate it exactly as the Newfoundland and Labrador guide does, after Benefield and others (1982). La Marzocco aims for 0.1 to 0.7.

Tea

There's no official water standard for tea, so we don't score it. Each water gets its USGS hardness class: soft up to 60 mg/L, moderately hard 61–120, hard 121–180, very hard above 180. The tea list sums up what lab studies found.

The other lists

For low sodium, magnesium, calcium and mineral content we use the EU's definitions for natural mineral waters (Directive 2009/54/EC, Annex III): sodium under 20 mg/L, magnesium over 50, calcium over 150, and dissolved solids of 50 or less (very low), 500 or less (low) and over 1,500 (rich). US labels don't use these, but they give every water the same yardstick. Fluoride is compared with the FDA's bottled water limits.

Updates and corrections

Brands publish new reports about once a year, and we reread them then. Older values stay on record, so a page can be updated without losing its history. If something looks wrong, tell us.